All-Americans

Columbus Wrestling All-Americans

NCAA

Charlie Sherertz 8th 1988

NCAA DII

Jay Sherer  National Champ 2010

Jay Sherer  4th 2011

Jay Sherer 7th 2009

NAIA

Rudy Glur National Champ 1980

Rudy Glur-3rd 1982

Kasten Grape 4th 2024

NJCAA

Rudy Glur 3rd 1979

Anthony Wilhelms 6th 1985

USA Wrestling Freestyle 

 Charlie Sherertz 3rd JR 1983

 Charlie Sherertz 2nd JR 1984

 Jay Sherer 5th SB 2002

Colton Wolfe 4th Cadet 2015 

 Kasten Grape 3rd SB 2016

USA Wrestling Greco

 Jay Sherer 5th SB 2002

 Kasten Grape 2nd SB 2016

Kasten Grape 7th JR 2019

Mason Petersen 5th 16u 2023

USA Wrestling Folkstyle

 Jay Sherer 2nd Cadet 2003

 Jay Sherer 1st Cadet 2004

 Wesley Cooper 4th Cadet 2004